Un fan que supuestamente estuvo en la listening party ha dicho varias cosas del disco en ATRL:
"The album will leave real music fans satisfied. ATRL will be severely confused, but I think they will appreciate a few songs."
"The song Million Reasons is a song about her fans. It's really inspiring and moving. Think Rachel Platten's "Fight Song"."
"Come To Mama probably received the strongest reaction so I'm surprised people didn't comment on it. People were LIVING for the lyrics and her delivery. It's very tongue-in-cheek with lyrics like "come to mama, i'll put on your pajamas, come to mama, i want no more drama" It's probably the most rock'n'roll sounding track on the album and the most fun one."
"If you like You & I, you will like John Wayne. Big rock singalong tea."
"Ayo, Diamond Heart and Angel Down are definitely going to be singles..."
"The album is more organic sounding than Perfect Illusion. More real instruments and less production, more stripped down moments, guitars, strings, piano, sax, etc."
"She doesn't do the rock vocal from Perfect Illusion and Dope on all songs. It's mostly in the ones with a stronger rock influence.
On the majority of her album, her voice sounds soothing. Even though there are some tougher tracks like PI, this album is more about showing Gaga's vulnerable side. And the vocals reflect that."
"Ayo is going to be a great song to perform live. It has that group energy like "We Will Rock You"."
"Angel Down (Work Tape) is piano and acoustic guitar only."
"Diamond Heart is a pop mid tempo love song. It's the beginning of the album, the moment of bliss and happiness she had while she was in love and then as the album goes on to explore heartbreak, rage, death, and ultimately finding strength in your darkness again."
"If Rolling Stones made a record inspired by Heavy Metal Lover, it would be Sinners Prayer. It sounds ****ing good."
"Here's 1 word for each track so I don't spoil too much
01. Diamond Heart = Big
02. A-Yo = Fun
03. Joanne = Light
04. John Wayne = Classic
05. Dancinâ In Circles = Funky
07. Million Reasons = Uplifting
08. Sinnerâs Prayer = Dark
09. Come To Mama = Sexy
10. Hey Girl = Sweet
11. Angel Down = Sad
12. Grigio Girls = Surprising
13. Just Another Day = Jazzy
14. Angel Down (Work Tape) = Raw"